Scotland to hold talks on new powers after renewed independence push.

Author:

Independence Campaign 2025 Annual Review - Believe in Scotland

Scotland is entering a pivotal phase in its pursuit of independence, as the Scottish National Party (SNP) intensifies efforts to secure a new referendum on the nation’s constitutional future. This movement is gaining momentum amidst a backdrop of shifting political dynamics and public sentiment.


 SNP’s Strategy for a New Independence Referendum

At the SNP’s 2025 annual conference in Aberdeen, First Minister John Swinney outlined a strategic approach to achieving a second independence referendum. The party has resolved that securing a majority of 65 seats in the upcoming May 2026 Scottish Parliament elections would serve as a clear mandate to pursue independence negotiations. This decision marks a departure from previous proposals for a “de facto referendum,” emphasizing a more structured and democratic path forward. (The Guardian)

Swinney’s stance is rooted in the belief that Scotland has reached the limits of its devolved powers and that independence is essential for the nation’s economic and social prosperity. He envisions an independent Scotland as a dynamic, fair society with the potential to leverage its vast renewable energy resources and rejoin the European Union. (Scottish National Party)


 Recent Publications: “A Fresh Start with Independence”

In October 2025, the Scottish Government released a new document titled “A Fresh Start with Independence.” This paper outlines the potential benefits of independence, including the possibility that each Scottish household could be £10,000 better off annually. The document argues that Scotland’s current constitutional arrangement limits its economic and social potential, advocating for a shift towards full sovereignty. (Wikipedia)

However, the publication has faced criticism from some pro-independence groups. Critics argue that the paper lacks specificity regarding key issues such as Scotland’s future membership in the European Union and NATO, and that it presents an overly optimistic view without addressing the complexities of transitioning to independence. (Wikipedia)


 Political Landscape and Public Opinion

The SNP’s renewed push for independence comes amid a changing political landscape in Scotland. Polling data indicates a generational shift in attitudes towards independence, with younger voters showing stronger support compared to older demographics. This trend suggests a growing base of pro-independence sentiment among the electorate. (Wikipedia)

However, the SNP faces challenges in achieving the required majority for a referendum. The proportional representation system in the Scottish Parliament means that securing 65 seats is a formidable task, necessitating broad support across various constituencies. (The Guardian)


 UK Government’s Position

The UK Government, led by Prime Minister Keir Starmer, maintains its stance against granting a second independence referendum. Starmer has reiterated that the 2014 referendum was a “once in a generation” event and that there is no mandate for another vote. This position has been a point of contention, with the SNP arguing that the political climate in Westminster has shifted, justifying a reconsideration of Scotland’s constitutional status. (Wikipedia)


 Looking Ahead

As Scotland approaches the 2026 elections, the debate over independence is expected to intensify. The SNP’s strategy to secure a clear mandate through electoral success underscores the party’s commitment to a democratic process. However, the path to independence remains fraught with political, economic, and constitutional challenges. The outcome of the upcoming elections will likely play a decisive role in shaping Scotland’s future relationship with the United Kingdom.

Independence Campaign 2025 Annual Review - Believe in Scotland

Scotland’s renewed push for independence has prompted significant discussions about devolved powers and alternative strategies for achieving constitutional change. Here are some key case studies and developments illustrating this dynamic:


1. SNP’s Strategy for a New Independence Referendum

At the 2025 SNP annual conference in Aberdeen, party members endorsed John Swinney’s strategy, asserting that a majority win—securing at least 65 seats—in the May 2026 Holyrood elections should be the sole valid route to triggering a new independence referendum. This approach was presented as a “clear and unambiguous” message for voters. The conference rejected an alternative amendment advocating for a more radical “de facto referendum” strategy, emphasizing the importance of clarity in messaging. (The Guardian)


2. “A Fresh Start with Independence” Paper

In October 2025, the Scottish Government released a new document titled “A Fresh Start with Independence.” This paper outlines the potential benefits of independence, including the possibility that each Scottish household could be £10,000 better off annually. The document argues that Scotland’s current constitutional arrangement limits its economic and social potential, advocating for a shift towards full sovereignty. (Scottish Government)


3. Alternative Proposals for Constitutional Change

Beyond the SNP’s strategy, other proposals have emerged within the independence movement:

  • Constitutional Convention: Some advocates suggest convening a constitutional convention to explore alternative paths to independence, such as unilateral declarations or international recognition. (AIIA)
  • International Appeals: Others propose seeking support from international bodies like the United Nations to gain recognition for Scotland’s right to self-determination. (AIIA)

These alternative strategies reflect the movement’s creativity and its deep internal divisions.


4. UK Government’s Position

The UK Government, led by Prime Minister Keir Starmer, maintains its stance against granting a second independence referendum. Starmer has reiterated that the 2014 referendum was a “once in a generation” event and that there is no mandate for another vote. This position has been a point of contention, with the SNP arguing that the political climate in Westminster has shifted, justifying a reconsideration of Scotland’s constitutional status. (Institute for Government)